People who just don’t get it

DC Movie Writer David Goyer does not get She-Hulk at all:

I could go on a long rant about how She-Hulk is not, in fact, a sex character but instead a fully realized woman with agency and competence, but the Internet has already obliged. I think this claim says a lot more about Mr. Goyer than it does about any issue of She-Hulk that’s ever been printed.

And here’s where I get into the feminism for a moment. This is something that some men do. Because someone is a good fit for one of their sexual fantasies (and hey, I totally get why someone might think She-Hulk is hitting all of his or her high points), they reduce her solely to this in their mind. Not usually so explicitly as this, but not too far off. And this happens to real people too, not just fictional characters. Never mind that the person on the other end did not agree to this objectification and in fact continues to live their actual life as someone who exists for more than someone else’s fantasies. Unless you’re talking about a character in a porn movie, this is a really bad mindset to get into.

And then beyond the She-Hulk thing, Mr. Goyer can’t help but take a pot-shot on comics fandom, falling into the whole adult male child who never has sex stereotype. Um, dude. Have you been in a comic shop in the last five years? To a convention? Over half of the attendees of Emerald City Comic Con in Seattle were women. All you’re saying with a crack like that is, “I am not part of your culture at all, and I don’t care enough to even know who you are.”

Can an outsider write a good comics movie? I really don’t think so. From the vantage point he’s taking, the source material is male power fantasy for underdeveloped men. That’s not what the comics themselves actually are, for the most part. Not the ones worth reading. Dear god, what’s he going to do with Wonder Woman? What are the odds he gives her a role beyond male sexual fantasy?

The best comics movies love their source material. You just can’t do it if you don’t inherently think there’s something noble and human about people like Tony Stark or Peter Parker. If you don’t capture the love, you end up with things like Man of Steel – loud, flashy, and heartless.

I was already skeptical of another Snyder-directed movie, but Batman vs. Superman: The Dawn of Justice just firmly dropped into the rent on home video list for me, and that only because I’m a superhero addict.

Minute Reviews: May 14, 2014 Releases

This is the first of possibly many weekly posts, where I give a short reaction to various books I’ve read this week. And that’s more minute as in small than as in time, but whatever works for you. (Got a better name? I’m happy to hear it.)

Astro City #12

Astro City #12The best of this week is, as is often the case, Astro City. While this issue isn’t feminist at all (the only women present are a girlfriend and daughter), it’s still brilliant. (And they just finished an arc featuring one of the most explicitly feminist characters in comics, Winged Victory.)

This is an in-depth character study of a villain. Nobody does character study like Astro City. This time it’s a fellow that likes to dress up super fancy and commit crimes. I’ve tried my hand at creating a universe of super heroes, and it’s not easy to come up with interesting superheroes, and I’m always amazed that Busiek can rattle them off like nobody else. The Sweet Adelines, a barbershop crime team? Wow.

There may very well be universes with better written comics than Astro City, but I’m convinced we’re not living in one of them.

Lumberjanes #2

Lumberjanes #2I’m in love with the Lumberjanes.

It’s sort of like an all-girl Goonies in the weird woods. It’s goofy, offbeat, and utterly charming. It’s impossible not to read it and try and decide who is your favorite lumberjane. (I think I’m on team April right now. She’s simultaneously both the most femme, and the most eager to go along with adventure, and I love this mix.)

Sometimes people think feminism means Wonder Woman and Xena, strong women kicking ass. And I like those things. But it also means Lumberjanes – a group of young women who are capable, interesting, and telling their own stories.

Also featuring my favorite fake merit badge ever!

Afterlife with Archie #5

If you haven’t heard of this title yet, it may be surprising. What it is, is a genuine zombie horror book. It’s scary, gory, and heartbreaking. The fact that these characters are all so familiar makes this a lot more emotionally effective than typical for the genre. And the artwork is just perfect. Horror fans and Archie fans, check this out! I’m not really one for zombies typically, but this is just executed flawlessly.

Life with Archie: The Married Life #35

This title is ending soon (with a much-spoiled twist, thanks comics press!) As often happens in these circumstances, there’s a rush to tie up storylines in this issue. It’s not quite as effective as typical, but I still stand by my claim that this is the best modern-day normal life comic since Strangers in Paradise. It’ll probably fall into an obscurity that it doesn’t deserve, because this is primo stuff.

Batgirl #31

Not a bad issue. A creepy villain, an advance of a long-term shadowy corporate adversary, and some screen time for Batgirl’s roommate Alesia. Who is one of the first major trans characters in the supporting cast of a mainstream comic, so I’m always happy to see her. It’s a good issue of a good comic.

Iron Man #25

I’ve liked a lot of Keiron Gillen’s work on things like Uncanny X-Men and the sublime Journey Into Mystery, but his Iron Man has been hit and miss. This issue gives Tony Stark a chance to totally kick some Dark Elf ass, which is satisfying, but does kind of go on after a bit. I liked it but am ready to move on from this storyline now.

Star Wars #17

It’s a shame that the Star Wars license is reverting to Marvel in a few months, because this is the best Star Wars comics have ever been. (It was inevitable, though, with Marvel’s parent company buying Star Wars from Lucas.) This issue had more action and fewer of the wonderful character moments that this run has been notable for, perhaps because of the aforementioned need to tie up storylines in the limited issues left.

Captain Marvel #3

Carol Danvers, now there’s a character that has a feminist sensibility. Fighter Pilot background, top billing in the Avengers roster, and a can-do, no-nonsense attitude. I love her, and I love this version of her, dropping the cheesecake aspects of her past and upping the depth. This issue is more of her gallivanting through space, like you do, and it’s fun.

Batman Eternal #6

DC’s weekly Batman series. I like the idea of weekly series so much – they can have a lot of momentum and pack in a bigger story than most comic pacing has pages for. This particular iteration is kind of all over the place – each issue seems to have limited relation to the earlier ones. One of those storylines, though, is Stephanie Brown, aka Spoiler, one of my favorite characters from the pre-new-52 era that got erased in the dubious reboot, and I’m in to see what they do with her. Which in this issue, is not appear. The Spectre shows up for some reason as they build tension about some mystical shit that is going to hit the fan along with all the other disparate elements introduced so far. If they can keep this all straight by the end and have a coherent story, it’ll be a miracle, but as messes go it’s pretty fun.

Shutter #2

An indy series about the daughter of some kind  of cross-dimensional explorer hero, who mostly wants to do her own thing and not follow in her father’s footsteps. The universe of weird has other ideas. I’m not sure really where this is going, but it’s interesting enough so far. I’m hoping for a little more agency to the main character soon, though.

All-New Ultimates #2

I like this team a lot. Not one of them is a white male. That’s pretty rare in superhero teams! Despite having All-New in the title, it’s actually a fairly been there, done that story, with a new team learning how to work together and not being as successful against a more cohesive group of villains on their first time out, and squabbling amongst themselves. Marvel publishes a lot of books like this – good superhero fare, but not groundbreaking particularly. (You could also read New Warriors, Mighty Avengers, or X-Men for the same itch!) Still, I like the team roster, and I like teen superhero team books, so I’m not disappointed.

Worlds’ Finest #23

I’m still happy that the put the apostrophe in the right place. It’s the little things in life. This is another book that’s fun but not blazing new ground, and I read because I like the roster. In this case it’s Power Girl, who is the Supergirl of Earth 2, and Huntress, who is the daughter of Batman and Catwoman from Earth 2, who get trapped in the main DC Universe and do their thing. Strong female characters doing their thing. Sure, I’ll read that.

Kevin Keller #13

I read this book because I’m just thrilled this book exists. Kevin is the gay teen in the Archie line. And this book is exactly like any other Archie comic (except the two earlier in this review!) Kevin has dating drama, but it’s all fairly low key. He has rivalries with the other kids, Reggie is kind of a jerk sometimes, Veronica uses him as her Gay Best Friend because of course she does, and for the most part the world treats him well and doesn’t give him trouble for being gay. I can only imagine what reading this title would mean to a teen gay boy, and I hope they keep publishing it for a long time.

Fables #140

Fables might be the second best Vertigo comic ever. (Behind Sandman, and in the same class as Books of Magic in my book.) It’s consistently great, and almost never has an issue that falls into cliches or shoddy storytelling. Unfortunately, almost never is not quite never, and this is the rare issue that isn’t that good. Well, still go back and read the collected editions of this Fairy Tale mish-mash epic. And we’re heading into the home stretch, with #150 announced as the series finale. And we’ll just kind of forget this little paint-by-numbers adventure happened.

All-New X-Men #27

In last year’s X-Men event, we were introduced to a team of Brotherhood of (Evil) Mutants from the future, with an interesting roster including a Mystique-esque shapeshifter and young Charles Xavier look-and-power-alike. This issue, for some reason they come back and attack this team of X-Men. There’s a lot of fighting, and some development of the two above mentioned Future Brotherhood members, who are both children of Mystique in the end. Whatever is going on here might be interesting once it’s revealed, but in this issue, it’s just chaos and confusion. And the backstory mentioned above isn’t really all that interesting. I think the future Brotherhood is one of those ideas that was more interesting when they were a mystery.

Whew! I don’t know if I’m going to write up this many every week (I read way too many comics!) so enjoy it.

We Are Comics

This is a brilliant idea:

In a nutshell, it’s a tumblr (which is a kind of blog, kind of) that posts stories of people that are part of the comics community. That are not the expected demographic.

It can feel awfully lonely out there in places, and some men really like a community that is all about them and resent the clubhouse doors being more open than ever before. That’s why it’s important for people to get out and say “I exist. You’re not alone. The bullies are wrong.”

That’s what I’m trying to do, at heart. And if I’m drowned out by other voices doing the same thing, that’s what winning looks like.

Link: Ms. Marvel, Comics, Diversity and Me

I’m in the busy season at my job, so while I’m a little short on energy for original content posts (though I have many swirling around my head), enjoy yet another fine link about Ms. Marvel, but really about diversity in comics and a changing society:

I couldn’t have said it better. And that’s not just a phrase – as a white woman, I’m not in the position to write this post! Which is why I seek out and share those that are in that position. I don’t mean that people in the position of power on an issue can’t write about it, but instead that those voices are easy to find, and it’s the other kind of story that’s a lot more interesting.

And I hope when I write about being a woman in comics fandom, and especially an LGBT one, people will find my voice adds something needed to the conversation.


Link: ECCC Gender Survey

A survey from Emerald City Comic Con in Seattle reveals that women outnumbered men:

No matter how you try and spin it, the conclusion is inescapable that women are involved in comic book culture in 2014. Which is why it’s important for publishers to realize their target demographic has shifted substantially and they aren’t just making power fantasies for 20-something straight white men any more. (And that itself is a shift from when they were for adolescent boys.)

Congratulations, publishers! For years and years, all anyone could talk about was how to break through to untapped demographic markets! Well, it turns out the key was making a series of very good and accessible blockbuster movies. Now we’re here, and a lot more women are dipping their toes into the comic book market. Let’s make sure there’s plenty of good stuff to find! Now is absolutely the critical time to care about this sort of thing!

Link: Check Out the First Three Issues of Ms. Marvel Right Now

From my favorite queer culture website:

I couldn’t agree more. Ms. Marvel is a rare gem. It’s an entertaining teen superhero romp with delightful art, and simultaneously a window into a culture that most of the readership (myself included) don’t know much about and is riveting. This is a risky book to publish, and exactly the kind of thing I urge people to support.

Link: Why the new Black Wally West is just offensive

Over at bleeding cool:

And he’s absolutely right. There are precious few non white male writers at DC and Marvel. And if you think that other people just aren’t interested – go to a comic con. Go to artist alley. Find people selling their indy comics. There are lots of black men, lots of women, sometimes even black women.

There are a few counter-examples – G.Willow Wilson is a muslim writing a muslim lead in Ms. Marvel, and Margerie Liu is Asian-American and writes a diverse cast on Astonishing X-Men. But mainstream comics that aren’t centered around white male culture are still very rare. (My favorite is probably Priest’s run on Black Panther in the 90s. If there ever was a book that benefited from an African-American writer….)

Our rallying cry is the same: Diversity makes for better stories. And by diversity we don’t mean Bendis or Johns writing about characters other than white men, nearly as much as we mean actually hiring some of the many talented, eager creators that are actively trying to get in the door. Ms. Marvel shouldn’t be the exception, it should be the start of something wonderful.

Obviously I’m going to write a post about Ms. Marvel soon, probably when the next issue drops!

Link: Five by Five

Here’s a good article on five of Marvel’s new women-led books:

I read all five of them, and they’re all worth checking out. It wasn’t long ago Marvel cancelled X-23 and had no women-led books, so kudos to them for taking the criticism to heart and fixing that. They also seem to be slowly hiring more women writers and artists, and it’s paying off nicely. There’s still even longer to go on that front, but these things take time.

Space Happens

Here’s a new kickstarter that looks interesting:

Basically, it’s a web series with the tagline: “A feminist satire of contemporary science fiction developed, written and produced by women in Chicago comedy”

These are all relevant things to my interest. (Including the Chicago, as it happens to be where I live.) It’s not comics, but comics and science fiction fandoms are intertwined so deeply, and I’m all about feminist satire of our cultures.

I backed it!